Fixes convergence discipline with four core changes:
1. Velocity redefined: velocity = open_tensions + new_perspectives
(work remaining, not score delta)
2. Unanimous convergence: 100% of experts must signal [MOVE:CONVERGE]
3. Both conditions required: velocity=0 AND converge=100%
4. Dialogues persist: stored in .blue/dialogues/<ISO>-<name>/
Database schema updates:
- Added score component columns (W/C/T/R breakdown)
- Added convergence tracking columns
- Created alignment_convergence_signals table
- Created alignment_scoreboard view
MCP tool updates:
- round_register accepts new metrics
- round_context returns convergence status
- verdict_register gates on convergence criteria
- dialogue_create outputs to .blue/dialogues/
- dialogue_export includes full scoreboard
Judge protocol updated with new scoreboard format and max_rounds=10.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
RFC 0051 accepted and initial implementation:
- Added alignment_dialogues, alignment_experts, alignment_rounds tables
- Added alignment_perspectives, alignment_tensions with event tracking
- Added alignment_recommendations, alignment_evidence, alignment_claims
- Added alignment_refs table for cross-entity references
- Added alignment_verdicts table for final/interim/minority verdicts
- Created alignment_db.rs module with database operations
- Created alignment-expert skill with marker syntax reference
Schema version bumped from 8 to 9.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Judge-driven panel evolution for alignment dialogues:
- Add `Graduated` as default rotation mode
- New `blue_dialogue_evolve_panel` tool for panel specification
- Panel sampling is now a suggestion (`suggested_panel`) not mandate
- Judge can override Round 0 panel before spawning agents
- Fresh experts (pool/created) get automatic context briefs
- Support for on-demand expert creation with focus areas
- Track panel history with source counts (retained/pool/created)
Key workflow changes:
- Phase 1: Review suggested panel, override if needed
- Phase 2+: Evolve panel based on dialogue dynamics
- `expert_source` param in round_prompt for context brief generation
Updates skill documentation with graduated rotation guidelines and
7 key rules including "REVIEW THE SUGGESTED PANEL".
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
