# Round 0 Scoreboard

## Expert Contributions

| Expert | Role | Tier | W | C | T | R | Score | Key Contribution |
|--------|------|------|---|---|---|---|-------|------------------|
| Muffin | Filesystem Architect | Core | 12 | 10 | 9 | 8 | **39** | Hash-prefix sharding, relations as directories |
| Cupcake | Knowledge Engineer | Core | 11 | 9 | 8 | 9 | **37** | Reification for n-ary, Event entity type |
| Scone | AI Agent Specialist | Core | 9 | 7 | 6 | 6 | **28** | Step 0 cache check, disambiguation gap |
| Eclair | DevEx Lead | Core | 10 | 8 | 7 | 7 | **32** | Symlink aliases, MANIFEST.md requirement |
| Donut | API Designer | Core | 9 | 10 | 8 | 7 | **34** | Slug grammar, delimiter change to `--` |
| Brioche | Systems Architect | Core | 13 | 11 | 10 | 9 | **43** | Relation index manifests, state semantics |
| Croissant | Database Architect | Adjacent | 10 | 9 | 7 | 8 | **34** | Secondary index files, query daemon |
| Macaron | Security Engineer | Adjacent | 9 | 8 | 8 | 6 | **31** | Classification metadata, access layer |
| Cannoli | Graph Theorist | Adjacent | 11 | 10 | 8 | 8 | **37** | Canonical ordering, schema requirement |
| Strudel | Cognitive Scientist | Adjacent | 10 | 8 | 7 | 6 | **31** | Expert-novice asymmetry, chunking reality |
| Beignet | Library Scientist | Wildcard | 14 | 9 | 9 | 10 | **42** | Faceted classification, authority control |
| Churro | Contrarian | Wildcard | 8 | 7 | 9 | 5 | **29** | Determinism fallacy, prove-it-first challenge |

**Round 0 Total: 417**

## Dimension Breakdown
- **Wisdom (W):** 126 - Strong perspective diversity
- **Consistency (C):** 106 - Good pattern following
- **Truth (T):** 96 - Well-grounded claims
- **Relationships (R):** 89 - Moderate cross-referencing

## Tensions Identified (Open)

| ID | Tension | Raised By | Status |
|----|---------|-----------|--------|
| T01 | Path brevity vs self-documentation | Muffin, Eclair, Strudel | OPEN |
| T02 | Hierarchical filesystem vs graph semantics | Muffin, Cannoli | OPEN |
| T03 | Determinism vs schema evolution | Muffin, Brioche | OPEN |
| T04 | Binary relations insufficient for n-ary | Muffin, Cupcake, Cannoli, Churro | OPEN |
| T05 | Closed-world entity types vs extensibility | Cupcake, Beignet | OPEN |
| T06 | Relation symmetry ambiguity | Cupcake, Cannoli | OPEN |
| T07 | Expert-novice encoding asymmetry | Strudel | OPEN |
| T08 | Determinism claim vs semantic ambiguity | Brioche, Churro | OPEN |
| T09 | State/entity boundary unclear | Brioche | OPEN |
| T10 | Relation query performance at scale | Croissant | OPEN |
| T11 | Greppability vs confidentiality | Macaron | OPEN |
| T12 | Traversal complexity vs modeling fidelity | Cannoli | OPEN |
| T13 | Notational hospitality (expansion capacity) | Beignet | OPEN |
| T14 | No implementation evidence | Churro | OPEN |

**Open Tensions: 14**
**New Perspectives: 47**

## Velocity Calculation

```
Velocity = Open Tensions + New Perspectives = 14 + 47 = 61
```

## Convergence Status

| Metric | Value |
|--------|-------|
| Open Tensions | 14 |
| New Perspectives | 47 |
| Velocity | 61 |
| Converge Signals | 0/12 (0%) |

**Status: NOT CONVERGED** - High velocity, many open tensions to resolve.

## Key Clusters Emerging

### Cluster A: Naming Convention
- Single-char vs full names (T01, T07)
- Experts: Muffin (pro-single), Eclair (pro-symlink-both), Strudel (pro-semantic)
- **Emerging consensus**: Symlink aliases (both forms available)

### Cluster B: Relation Modeling
- Binary insufficiency (T04, T06, T12)
- Experts: Muffin, Cupcake, Cannoli, Donut, Churro
- **Emerging consensus**: Reification pattern + canonical ordering + `--` delimiter

### Cluster C: Extensibility
- Closed entity types (T05, T13)
- Experts: Cupcake, Beignet
- **Emerging consensus**: Add `/_custom/` or `/f/` facets layer

### Cluster D: Scalability
- Directory limits, relation queries (T10)
- Experts: Muffin, Croissant, Brioche
- **Emerging consensus**: Hash-prefix sharding + secondary index files

### Cluster E: Security Gap
- No security model (T11)
- Experts: Macaron
- **Emerging consensus**: Classification metadata + access layer (needs more discussion)

### Cluster F: Determinism Reality Check
- Semantic ambiguity remains (T08, T14)
- Experts: Brioche, Churro
- **Emerging consensus**: Acknowledge limits explicitly, prove with implementation

## Round 1 Focus Areas

1. **Resolve T01/T07**: Lock naming convention decision (symlink aliases?)
2. **Resolve T04/T06**: Lock relation modeling approach (reification + canonical + `--`)
3. **Resolve T05/T13**: Define extensibility mechanism
4. **Address T14**: Define proof-of-concept requirements
5. **Address T08**: Clarify what "deterministic" actually means given disambiguation needs