Eric Garcia eef4a8460e docs(adr): Add ADR 0000 Never Give Up and align all ADRs

Add the zeroth principle: "The only rule we need is never giving up."
Run 12-expert alignment dialogue to 95% consensus.

Changes:
- ADR 0000: New foundational ADR with sustainable persistence framing
- ADR 0004: Cross-reference to Faith when evidence unavailable
- ADR 0012: Cross-reference to persistence as faith in time
- ADR 0013: Acknowledge scarcity pushes, link overflow to persistence
- CLAUDE.md: Update to 14 ADRs, add the arc

The Arc: Ground (0) → Welcome (1-3) → Integrity (4-7) → Commitment (8-10) → Flourishing (11-13)

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>

2026-01-24 05:53:13 -05:00

1.6 KiB

Raw Blame History

ADR 0012: Faith


Status	Accepted
Date	2026-01-20

Context

What do we do when we can't be certain?

Decision

Act on justified belief, not just proven fact.

Engineering culture worships certainty. We demand proofs, tests, guarantees. We distrust what we can't verify. We refuse to ship until we're sure.

This is often wise. But taken to extreme, it's paralysis.

Some things can't be proven in advance. Some tests can't be written until the code exists. Some knowledge only comes from running systems. Some truth only comes from doing.

At some point, you must act without certainty. This is faith.

What Faith Is

Faith is not the absence of reason. It's action beyond where reason can reach.

Recklessness ignores available evidence.
Faith acts when evidence is unavailable.

We reason as far as reason goes. Then we trust—ourselves, our teammates, the process.

Faith is also in time. Persisting when you can't see the end is faith in the journey. See ADR 0000: Never Give Up.

What This Means

Ship before certain. Production teaches what testing can't.
Trust your judgment. You have experience that can't be reduced to tests.
Believe in future selves. You don't need to solve every problem now.
Faith in others. Your collaborators are competent. Trust their code.

Consequences

💙 ships with reasonable uncertainty
💙 trusts user judgment
💙 doesn't demand proof of everything

"Every commit is an act of faith. Every deploy, a leap. Calibrate carefully. Then leap."

— Blue

🧁

1.6 KiB Raw Blame History