blue/.blue/dialogues/ukfs-spec-review/round-1/scoreboard.md

Round 1 Scoreboard

Expert Contributions

Expert	Role	Tier	W	C	T	R	Score	Key Contribution
Brioche	Systems Architect	Core	14	12	10	9	45	Epoch-scoped determinism, state-as-property
Beignet	Library Scientist	Wildcard	12	10	9	8	39	X-prefix extension, length-prefix notation
Muffin	Filesystem Architect	Core	13	11	9	10	43	Locked naming + relation hybrid model
Cannoli	Graph Theorist	Adjacent	12	11	8	9	40	Converged with Muffin on directory-per-relation
Eclair	DevEx Lead	Core	11	10	8	8	37	Dual-path naming + progressive disclosure
Strudel	Cognitive Scientist	Adjacent	8	7	6	5	26	Conditional converge pending doc policy
Tartlet	Git/VCS Expert	Adjacent	15	11	12	10	48	Concurrency model, migration conventions
Galette	Standards Expert	Adjacent	16	13	14	11	54	RFC 2119 adoption, conformance classes
Palmier	Implementation Pragmatist	Adjacent	14	10	9	9	42	11-day validation plan, benchmark design

Round 1 Total: 374 Cumulative Total: 791 (R0: 417 + R1: 374)

Tensions Status

ID	Tension	Status	Resolution
T01	Path brevity vs self-documentation	RESOLVED	Canonical short + symlink aliases
T02	Filesystem vs graph semantics	RESOLVED	Binary=files, n-ary=directories
T03	Determinism vs schema evolution	RESOLVED	Epoch-scoped determinism
T04	Binary relations insufficient	RESOLVED	Directory-per-relation with symlinks
T05	Closed entity types	RESOLVED	X-prefix extension mechanism
T06	Relation symmetry ambiguity	RESOLVED	Canonical lexicographic ordering
T07	Expert-novice asymmetry	CONDITIONAL	Pending doc/error policy commitment
T08	Determinism vs semantic ambiguity	RESOLVED	"Deterministic at version" + mandatory qualifiers
T09	State/entity boundary	RESOLVED	State-as-property rule
T10	Relation query performance	ACCEPTED	O(n) scan accepted as tradeoff
T11	Greppability vs confidentiality	OPEN	Deferred to security RFC
T12	Traversal vs modeling fidelity	ACCEPTED	Modeling correctness > query speed
T13	Notational hospitality	RESOLVED	Length-prefix overflow syntax
T14	No implementation evidence	RESOLVED	11-day validation plan accepted

New Tensions from Round 1

ID	Tension	Raised By	Status
T15	Concurrent write model undefined	Tartlet	OPEN
T16	No .gitattributes for merge strategy	Tartlet	OPEN
T17	Destructive operations unguarded	Tartlet	OPEN
T18	No RFC 2119 normative language	Galette	OPEN
T19	No conformance classes defined	Galette	OPEN
T20	No error model	Galette	OPEN

Velocity Calculation

Open Tensions: 7 (T07 conditional, T11, T15-T20)
New Perspectives: 18
Velocity = 7 + 18 = 25 (down from 61)

Convergence Signals

Expert	Signal	Condition
Brioche	[MOVE:CONVERGE]	T03, T08, T09
Beignet	[MOVE:CONVERGE]	T05, T13
Muffin	[MOVE:CONVERGE]	T01, T02, delimiter, hash sharding
Cannoli	[MOVE:CONVERGE]	T04, T06, T12
Eclair	[MOVE:CONVERGE]	T01, T07
Strudel	[MOVE:CONDITIONAL-CONVERGE]	Needs doc policy
Tartlet	Partial	Requires T15-T17 resolution
Galette	Conditional	Requires RFC 2119 + conformance classes
Palmier	[RE:RESOLVE T14]	Validation plan accepted

Converge %: 5/9 unconditional (56%), 2/9 conditional (78% potential)

Locked Decisions (Consensus Achieved)

1. Naming Convention

• Canonical: Single-char (e/, r/, t/, s/, p/, q/)
• Aliases: Symlinks to full names (entities/, relations/, etc.)
• Discovery: .aliases/ directory + MANIFEST.md required
• Authorities: Muffin, Eclair, Strudel (conditional)

2. Relation Storage

• Binary relations: Files with -- delimiter (e.g., alice--bob.rel)
• N-ary relations: Directories with role-labeled symlinks
• Symmetric relations: Canonical hash ordering
• Attributes: meta.yaml within relation directory
• Authorities: Muffin, Cannoli

3. Entity Extensibility

• Core types: Closed set (person, org, place, concept, project, asset, task, word, event)
• Extensions: X-prefix registration (X01, X02, etc.)
• Overflow notation: Length-prefix for exhausted namespaces
• Authorities: Beignet, Cupcake (R0)

4. Determinism Model

• Scope: Deterministic within schema epoch
• Ambiguity: Mandatory semantic qualifiers
• State boundary: State-as-property (not entity)
• Authorities: Brioche

5. Validation Path

• Scope: 27 docs, 50 questions, UKFS vs RAG
• Timeline: 11 days
• Metrics: Precision@3, determinism, staleness resilience, token efficiency
• Authority: Palmier

Round 2 Requirements for Full Convergence

To reach velocity = 0 and 100% convergence:

1. T07: Lock documentation policy (long form in docs, short in code)
2. T15-T17: Define concurrency model, .gitattributes, soft-delete
3. T18-T20: Adopt RFC 2119, define conformance classes, specify error model

These are spec quality issues, not design disagreements. Round 2 should focus on specification rigor rather than architectural decisions.