blue/.blue/dialogues/ukfs-spec-review/round-0/scoreboard.md

Round 0 Scoreboard

Expert Contributions

Expert	Role	Tier	W	C	T	R	Score	Key Contribution
Muffin	Filesystem Architect	Core	12	10	9	8	39	Hash-prefix sharding, relations as directories
Cupcake	Knowledge Engineer	Core	11	9	8	9	37	Reification for n-ary, Event entity type
Scone	AI Agent Specialist	Core	9	7	6	6	28	Step 0 cache check, disambiguation gap
Eclair	DevEx Lead	Core	10	8	7	7	32	Symlink aliases, MANIFEST.md requirement
Donut	API Designer	Core	9	10	8	7	34	Slug grammar, delimiter change to --
Brioche	Systems Architect	Core	13	11	10	9	43	Relation index manifests, state semantics
Croissant	Database Architect	Adjacent	10	9	7	8	34	Secondary index files, query daemon
Macaron	Security Engineer	Adjacent	9	8	8	6	31	Classification metadata, access layer
Cannoli	Graph Theorist	Adjacent	11	10	8	8	37	Canonical ordering, schema requirement
Strudel	Cognitive Scientist	Adjacent	10	8	7	6	31	Expert-novice asymmetry, chunking reality
Beignet	Library Scientist	Wildcard	14	9	9	10	42	Faceted classification, authority control
Churro	Contrarian	Wildcard	8	7	9	5	29	Determinism fallacy, prove-it-first challenge

Round 0 Total: 417

Dimension Breakdown

• Wisdom (W): 126 - Strong perspective diversity
• Consistency (C): 106 - Good pattern following
• Truth (T): 96 - Well-grounded claims
• Relationships (R): 89 - Moderate cross-referencing

Tensions Identified (Open)

ID	Tension	Raised By	Status
T01	Path brevity vs self-documentation	Muffin, Eclair, Strudel	OPEN
T02	Hierarchical filesystem vs graph semantics	Muffin, Cannoli	OPEN
T03	Determinism vs schema evolution	Muffin, Brioche	OPEN
T04	Binary relations insufficient for n-ary	Muffin, Cupcake, Cannoli, Churro	OPEN
T05	Closed-world entity types vs extensibility	Cupcake, Beignet	OPEN
T06	Relation symmetry ambiguity	Cupcake, Cannoli	OPEN
T07	Expert-novice encoding asymmetry	Strudel	OPEN
T08	Determinism claim vs semantic ambiguity	Brioche, Churro	OPEN
T09	State/entity boundary unclear	Brioche	OPEN
T10	Relation query performance at scale	Croissant	OPEN
T11	Greppability vs confidentiality	Macaron	OPEN
T12	Traversal complexity vs modeling fidelity	Cannoli	OPEN
T13	Notational hospitality (expansion capacity)	Beignet	OPEN
T14	No implementation evidence	Churro	OPEN

Open Tensions: 14 New Perspectives: 47

Velocity Calculation

Velocity = Open Tensions + New Perspectives = 14 + 47 = 61

Convergence Status

Metric	Value
Open Tensions	14
New Perspectives	47
Velocity	61
Converge Signals	0/12 (0%)

Status: NOT CONVERGED - High velocity, many open tensions to resolve.

Key Clusters Emerging

Cluster A: Naming Convention

• Single-char vs full names (T01, T07)
• Experts: Muffin (pro-single), Eclair (pro-symlink-both), Strudel (pro-semantic)
• Emerging consensus: Symlink aliases (both forms available)

Cluster B: Relation Modeling

• Binary insufficiency (T04, T06, T12)
• Experts: Muffin, Cupcake, Cannoli, Donut, Churro
• Emerging consensus: Reification pattern + canonical ordering + -- delimiter

Cluster C: Extensibility

• Closed entity types (T05, T13)
• Experts: Cupcake, Beignet
• Emerging consensus: Add /_custom/ or /f/ facets layer

Cluster D: Scalability

• Directory limits, relation queries (T10)
• Experts: Muffin, Croissant, Brioche
• Emerging consensus: Hash-prefix sharding + secondary index files

Cluster E: Security Gap

• No security model (T11)
• Experts: Macaron
• Emerging consensus: Classification metadata + access layer (needs more discussion)

Cluster F: Determinism Reality Check

• Semantic ambiguity remains (T08, T14)
• Experts: Brioche, Churro
• Emerging consensus: Acknowledge limits explicitly, prove with implementation

Round 1 Focus Areas

1. Resolve T01/T07: Lock naming convention decision (symlink aliases?)
2. Resolve T04/T06: Lock relation modeling approach (reification + canonical + --)
3. Resolve T05/T13: Define extensibility mechanism
4. Address T14: Define proof-of-concept requirements
5. Address T08: Clarify what "deterministic" actually means given disambiguation needs