superviber/blue
2
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull requests Projects Releases Packages Wiki Activity Actions
blue/.blue/dialogues/ukfs-spec-review/round-1/context-brief.md
Eric Garcia 6e8f0db6c0 chore: add dialogues, RFCs, docs and minor improvements 
- Add dialogue prompt file writing for audit/debugging
- Update README install instructions
- Add new RFCs (0053, 0055-0059, 0062)
- Add recorded dialogues and expert pools
- Add ADR 0018 dynamodb-portable-schema
- Update TODO with hook configuration notes

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-02-26 08:51:56 -05:00

2.2 KiB
Raw Blame History

Round 1 Context Brief

Round 0 Summary

12 experts analyzed the UKFS specification. Key findings:

Emerging Consensus

  1. Naming Convention: Symlink aliases providing both forms (e/ AND entities/) is gaining support
  2. Relation Modeling: Reification for n-ary + canonical ordering for symmetric + -- delimiter instead of +
  3. Scalability: Hash-prefix sharding (e/person/a8/alice/) + secondary index files
  4. Event Entity Type: Add /e/event/ as first-class type
  5. Schema Layer: Add /.schema/ for type definitions

Open Tensions Requiring Resolution

ID Tension Key Question
T01 Single-char vs full names Lock the naming decision
T04 Binary relations insufficient Confirm reification approach
T05 Closed entity types Define extensibility mechanism
T08 Determinism vs semantic ambiguity Clarify what "deterministic" means
T14 No implementation evidence Define proof-of-concept scope

Key Perspectives from Round 0

  • Muffin: "Single-char roots are correct. Hash-prefix sharding for scale. Relations should be directories, not files."
  • Cupcake: "Add Event entity type. Use reification for n-ary relations. Define extensibility via /_custom/."
  • Eclair: "Provide symlink aliases for both forms. Require MANIFEST.md in each directory."
  • Brioche: "Add relation index manifests per entity. Define state semantics explicitly."
  • Cannoli: "Canonical lexicographic ordering for symmetric relations. Accept O(n) scan cost for attributes."
  • Beignet: "Adopt faceted auxiliary layer (/f/). Implement authority control for synonyms."
  • Churro: "Prove it first. Define anti-goals. Determinism claim is overstated."

Round 1 Objectives

  1. Lock T01: Decide naming convention (single-char canonical + symlink aliases?)
  2. Lock T04: Confirm relation modeling (reification + -- delimiter + canonical ordering?)
  3. Lock T05: Define extensibility (/_custom/? /f/ facets? Both?)
  4. Address T08: Reframe "deterministic" claim accurately
  5. Address T14: Define minimum viable proof-of-concept

Experts should build on Round 0 insights and drive toward convergence on these decisions.